The Wagner Journal
David Syrus, Review of Webb, ‘Variants in Wagner’s Vocal Lines’
David Syrus, Review of Webb, ‘Variants in Wagner’s Vocal Lines’
Couldn't load pickup availability
Review of Susan Webb, Variants in Wagner’s Vocal Lines: The ‘Ring’ Operas (Leyerle Publications, 2000).
March 2007, Volume 1, Number 1, 51–3.
To monitor his singers, Beckmesser has the Tabulatur. Wagner suggests to us that this is a fairly fixed, unyielding set of guidelines. We répétiteurs – latterday Beckmessers? – have nothing so reliable to work with. Our scores, whether with piano accompaniments or with the full orchestration, are full of anomalies. How could it be otherwise? A modern composer with Sibelius software can in theory produce a perfect account on paper of his intentions. An editor working from written manuscripts from the days before computers must always to a certain extent be using subjective criteria. Where exactly does that phrase end? Is that a staccato dot over the note (meaning play it short) or is it a ‘wedge’ (meaning give it a decisive, rather longer accent)?